The Banshees of Inisherin is a wonderful, dark comedy, drama film that follows two Irishmen as their friendship unravels. This film reunites stars Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson with director Martin McDonagh, who first worked together on the cult-classic film, In Bruges. This slow burn of a movie feels like it easily could have been adapted from the stage as fantastic actors combine with a great script to deliver a remarkable piece of cinema.
Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson star as two best friends Pádraic and Colm, who live normal, boring lives on the fictional island of Inisherin set off the coast of the real island of Ireland. The movie begins as Colm decides to end his friendship with Pádraic for unknown reasons and what follows are the ramifications of that decision. Pádraic lives on the island with his sister Siobhan played by Kerry Condon and interacts with the village idiot, Dominic, played by Barry Keoghan. I will discuss the greatness of this script more, but I will first give credit to these four actors who just bring something truly incredible to the screen and this world feels real and lived in largely because of the performances. Farrell is able to convey so much heart and honesty as Pádraic and Gleeson is fantastic as the older, wiser, and more distant Colm. Kerry Condon’s performance is elegantly dedicated to her role as the lonely, reasonable woman, and Keoghan seems to act with every muscle in his body as the dimwitted, lovable Dominic. Thanks to these actors, it was only when the credits rolled that I remembered I was watching a movie at all.
Martin McDonagh once again proves that he makes great movies as he sits in the director’s chair for The Banshees of Inisherin. The setting of this movie is perfectly chosen, and the technical aspects are simple but beautiful. Shots of beautiful pastoral landscapes and sea-battered cliffs further accentuate the reality of this community and the separation from the mainland. McDonagh frames it all with a cool colour palette of blues and greens blanketed in mist. McDonagh also has the main writing credit for The Banshees which is really the mosaic of a foundation that everything else stands upon. The premise of the story is simple and ultimately relatable, but the journey can be quite unexpected. The dynamics between characters are active and true, providing touchstones and viewpoints into motivations and overall themes. There is humor here, and some great wit to these Irish folk that lend to this movie being quite funny. It is comparable to reading a great novel. I think about the feeling after reading works like Moby Dick by Herman Melville or The Sportswriter by Richard Ford. These classic novels may not be the most exciting examples of the written word, but they are great examples of well-crafted and well written stories. It actually is also comparable to a Shakespearean play, but perhaps slightly less grand. It’s not a feeling I could pin down immediately after the credits rolled, but something that grew on me over time.
The Banshees of Inisherin is a slow-paced character study, and it’s not a movie for everyone. There is no feeling of elitism to this movie that makes me think that, but I can see the nature of the story not being the most enjoyable for everybody. Also, not everybody likes or enjoys reading. Themes about the strength of friendship and love circle around ideas about ambition and legacy, set to the backdrop of the Irish Civil War. The island of Inisherin is removed from the fighting but occasional reverberations reach this community adding subtle layers to everything else.
All-in-all Martin McDonagh and the team have crafted an excellent film that feels unique. There were some aspects that still fell flat, and the pacing and accessibility will just barely keep it from my perfect score, but I can see this movie being a highlight of awards season. I feel fairly certain that upon rewatching, I will regret not giving The Banshees of Inisherin a 5/5, but upon first watch I don’t think, as a whole, it’s exactly perfect (but it is very, very good). This is a high recommendation for anybody that enjoys watching theatre productions, reading Shakespeare, or studying literature. I would still give this as a recommendation for anyone that even thinks they might enjoy this funny, tragic, character driven, great film.
4.5/5